ClearThinker helps product managers and their teams achieve more through 1:1 coaching and consulting.

Thoughts on Product Leadership

Making NPS More Useful for Product Managers

Net Promoter Score (NPS) is widespread in measuring customer satisfaction, but more is needed from it for product managers. It tells if customers value a product but not what they like or why they’re unhappy. 

What is an NPS Score?

NPS is a customer loyalty and satisfaction benchmark. It is derived from a single question probing the customer’s likelihood to recommend a product or service. 

On a scale from 0-10, how likely are you to recommend us to a friend or colleague?

This score is a forecasting tool for repurchases and referrals, pivotal for a company’s growth trajectory. NPS offers a swift assessment of market reception and doubles as an overall satisfaction and brand loyalty indicator. It simplifies complex customer sentiments into data.

Calculating NPS

Net Promoter Score (NPS) is not a straightforward metric for customer loyalty. 

Responses are bucketed into three categories: Promoters, Passives, and Detractors.

Customers scoring 9 to 10 are Promoters whose loyalty and referrals contribute to growth. 

Those with scores of 7 to 8, categorized as Passives, show satisfaction without solid loyalty. 

Customers scoring 6 or below, the Detractors, express dissatisfaction that can harm a brand’s growth. 

Notably, passive scores are excluded from the NPS calculation as their impact is neutral.

To calculate NPS, subtract the percentage of detractors from the percentage of promoters. Scores can range from -100 (all Detractors) to +100 (all Promoters).

For example, if 60% of respondents are Promoters and 30% are Detractors, your NPS score would be 30. Similarly, if only 15% are Promoters and 60% are Detractors, your NPS score would be -45.

Interpreting NPS

NPS stands as a significant indicator of a company’s standing with customers. High scores often mean customers will likely become brand advocates, leading to lower acquisition costs and higher retention rates. 

It’s a trailing measure hinting at the user’s past experiences. However, research by Bain & Company shows that NPS leaders typically double their competitors’ growth rates, making it a good indicator of future performance. Customers who contribute to a high NPS also tend to have higher lifetime value, demonstrating loyalty and a propensity for repeat business. A strong NPS is also linked to an enhanced online presence, drawing in more customers.

NPS not only reflects current customer satisfaction but also forecasts future business growth. Higher than average NPS scores in a sector often correlate with superior organic growth. It predicts customer behaviors central to growth, such as repurchasing and referrals. The one-question format of NPS surveys yields higher participation, providing robust data. Moreover, it captures the perspectives of the most loyal customers, the ones most likely to recommend a company, amplifying the impact of word-of-mouth marketing.

NPS stands out for its simplicity and versatility. The calculation is straightforward, enhancing its accessibility across all levels of an organization. Its brevity typically results in high response rates, yielding actionable data. NPS’s uniform approach allows for cross-industry and cross-cultural loyalty comparisons. It can be seamlessly woven into various customer interaction points, and its adaptability extends to gauging employee satisfaction, demonstrating its broad applicability.

Challenges with NPS

NPS offers a measure of customer sentiment but lacks any context behind the scores. It groups complex customer emotions into broad categories — promoters, passives, and detractors — without pinpointing the exact reasons for these sentiments. This lack of detail hampers the ability to undertake targeted actions. 

Product managers are often compelled to conduct secondary surveys or interviews to extract more profound insights. Sole reliance on NPS might lead to generic, wide-ranging business strategies that fail to address specific customer concerns.

Expanding NPS

Expanding the NPS survey to include a follow-up question such as:

“Why did you give this score?”

“What can we do better to increase this score?” 

can unlock critical insights for product managers. This additional query digs into the reasoning behind a customer’s score, revealing specific drivers of satisfaction or dissatisfaction. Product managers can pinpoint exact areas for improvement or reinforcement by understanding the’ why’ behind the score. This targeted feedback is invaluable for prioritizing product features, enhancements, and customer experience strategies aligned with customer needs and perceptions.

Confirmation Bias

Confirmation bias in interpreting NPS poses a significant risk. A high NPS can lead companies to disregard crucial feedback, creating a false sense of security and complacency towards innovation.  It’s important to remember that external factors can skew NPS, which might misrepresent actual product sentiment if considered alone. 

Product managers fixated on NPS may overlook broader aspects of customer experience. Additionally, there’s a tendency to selectively use positive NPS feedback to reinforce existing beliefs about a product’s success, thus ignoring valuable critical feedback.

How To Use NPS as a Product Manager

For product managers, NPS serves as guide for informing product development priorities. High scores typically point to valued features, directing resource investment effectively. Addressing issues highlighted by NPS can markedly enhance customer loyalty. 

Tracking NPS over time aids in identifying and acting on consistent customer sentiment trends. 

Segmenting NPS allows for focused feature enhancement for specific customer groups. 

Lastly, categorizing feedback into themes enables tackling widespread issues, ensuring systemic problems are addressed rather than isolated incidents.

Pro Tip

Collecting NPS at the feature level can yield granular insights into your product’s performance. By asking customers to score individual features, you can gather precise data on which aspects drive loyalty and which need refinement. Use these insights to make data-driven decisions on where to allocate resources, which features to promote, and where to innovate. This targeted approach ensures that every element of your product aligns with customer needs and maximizes overall satisfaction.

Address Detractors

Detractor engagement is crucial for product managers. Vocal detractors often give specific feedback, driving substantial improvements. Turning detractors into passives or promoters significantly boosts NPS and overall sentiment. Addressing their concerns is critical to reducing churn and shaping product strategy. Engagement demonstrates a commitment to all customer segments, enhancing brand loyalty. Detractors also shed light on competitive gaps, suggesting areas for differentiation.

Using NPS in Practice

Incorporating NPS wisely is essential for product managers. It should complement other KPIs, avoiding dependence on this single metric alone. Benchmarking against industry standards is critical to contextualize NPS. 

NPS is a feedback mechanism, not an isolated growth lever; it must inform wider strategic choices. Analyzing NPS alongside behavioral data offers a more nuanced view, guiding smarter decisions. Additionally, proper training on NPS interpretation is vital for teams to sidestep errors that can result in misguided actions and resource allocation.

Integrating Qualitative Feedback

Effective utilization of NPS data is more than just number crunching. It involves delving into verbatim survey responses to extract qualitative insights. Incorporating this feedback into the product development cycle ensures features meet customer expectations. NPS feedback also shapes service and support strategies beyond mere product tweaks. Actioning on this feedback can significantly elevate customer satisfaction and encourage positive endorsements. Furthermore, NPS insights can influence strategies across functions, guiding marketing and product design decisions.

Monitoring NPS

Monitoring NPS trends is essential for understanding how product updates and market dynamics affect customer loyalty. Over time, these trends map the trajectory of customer commitment, providing insights into what works. A steady rise in NPS often reflects product enhancements resonating with users. Conversely, a decline can signal underlying problems, necessitating quick action. Additionally, recognizing patterns, such as seasonal fluctuations in NPS, can assist in anticipating and preparing for changes in customer engagement.

Segmentation

Analyzing NPS through customer segmentation sharpens the focus on specific groups’ satisfaction levels. It directs enhancements to address unique user group needs, bolstering personalization. This stratification aids in devising communication strategies that resonate more effectively with distinct segments. Insights from segment-specific NPS scores inform product direction, ensuring varied customer expectations are met. Additionally, segmentation analysis can spotlight niche markets or evolving trends, shaping strategic planning.

Additional Metrics

Customer Effort Score (CES)

Beyond NPS, the Customer Effort Score (CES) gauges the ease customers can use a product or service. It’s a key indicator of loyalty, with a lower CES often translating to higher loyalty. It predicts future buying behavior, as minimal effort can lead to repeat business. In service industries, CES is vital as quick, easy resolutions are paramount for customer satisfaction. Focusing on reducing customer effort can lead to efficiency and customer contentment gains.

Customer Satisfaction (CSAT)

Customer Satisfaction (CSAT) is a metric that zeros in on a customer’s satisfaction level at a specific point of interaction. This immediate measure allows for quick feedback on various facets of the customer experience, pinpointing areas that need refinement. Unlike NPS, CSAT offers a detailed view of satisfaction, often reflecting customer sentiment directly after an interaction. This can correlate with short-term loyalty. Additionally, CSAT is instrumental in evaluating the impact of recent product or service updates, providing a snapshot of their success and informing future enhancements.

Putting it All Together

While NPS provides a broad stroke of customer loyalty and potential for growth, it must be leveraged with other metrics like CES and CSAT for a comprehensive view. CES assesses the effort customers expend, which correlates with loyalty and repeat business, while CSAT captures immediate satisfaction, useful for pinpointing specific areas of improvement. Together, these metrics offer a multi-dimensional view of customer experience, guiding product managers to make informed, impactful decisions. A nuanced approach, combining trend analysis and customer segmentation with these diverse metrics, ensures that strategies are well-rounded and customer-centric.